a page of madness

film writing by nicholas vroman

Archive for March 2011

REVIEW: Haru’s Journey

leave a comment »

春との旅 (Haru to no tabi)

Released: 2010

Masahiro Kobayashi

Tatsuya Nakadai
Eri Tokunaga
Hideji Ohtaki
Kin Sugai
Yuko Tanaka

Running time: 134 min.

Reviewed by Nicholas Vroman

Masahiro Kobayashi, who’s developed a cultish following – largely outside Japan, is probably best known in his early films for his French New Wave homages and in his later films for his repetitive and austere style applied to deep social critiques of contemporary Japan. This austere toward boring style is mostly what has divided fans and critics. I fall into the realm of fandom.

What’s often overlooked in the big picture of Kobayashi’s oeuvre is his delicate and sensitive work with a who’s who of Japanese actors. Akira Emoto, hot off “Dr. Akagi,” camped it up in “Kaizobukan Bootleg Film” (1999). The film that marks the beginning of the Kobayashi style, 2001’s “Man Walking on Snow,” was a vehicle for Ken Ogata. Teriyuki Kagawa appears in many of his films. Ryo Ishibashi took the starring role in “Shiawase” (2006). And Makiko Watanabe was brilliant carrying a largely silent role in “The Rebirth” against Kobayshi-san himself, no slouch of an actor himself.

When the doors of a ramshackle seaside cabin burst open and the angry Tadao limps out, bellowing, casting off his cane, followed by his distraught granddaughter, Haru, one knows one’s on for a ride of actorly chops and a new challenge for Tatsuya Nakadai. As Tadao, the old washed-up failure of a herring fisherman, Nakadai brings a not only an honor and grandeur to this role (remember, this is Nakadai!) but exposes his many flaws and problems, often only through gestures and glances. Eri Tokugawa as Haru, lumbering with the same bowlegged walk as Nakadai and wearing particularly frumpy clothes goes against her usual model cuteness, She naturally plays off the almost infantile emotionality of her grandfather accepting reluctantly the adultness thrust upon her.

“Haru’s Journey” is a road movie, taking our two heroes south from Hokkaido in search of a home for Tadao and work for Haru. This simple premise reveals a hard look into family dynamics and the unraveling social contract in contemporary Japan with a very forgiving viewpoint.

Tadao, nearing the end of his rope – and his life – hits the road with his granddaughter, Haru. First he goes to his well-off older brother, Shigeo (Hideji Otaki) and his wife, Keiko (Kin Sugai). Pride and old family hurts keep Tadao from accepting an old storage room in which to spend his final days. Plus, Keiko reveals that she and her husband are moving to a retirement home anyway.

He then searches for his brother, Yukio, last whereabouts, prison, current whereabouts unknown. They meet his partner, Aiko (Yuko Tanaka) a simple, hard-working woman, who can offer little but a good ear. Next they move on to his older sister, Shigeko (Chikage Awashima), ryokan owner and self-made woman. She’s happy to have Haru work for her, but Tadao, becoming kidlike in his older sister’s presence brings out his last vestige of male pride and moves on. Finding his remaining younger brother, Michio (Akira Emoto) brings the deep-seated family tensions to a head, resulting in argument and a fight. But even this loutish brother has a bit of heart, paying for a hotel for the travelers even though he’s really in debt up to his ears.

The final chapter leads Haru and Tadao to a sylvan island where Haru’s estranged father, Shinichi (Teruyuki Kagawa) lives with his new wife Nobuko (Naho Toda), raising horses. Shinichi had left Haru and her mother (Tadao’s daughter) years before because of an affair Haru’s mother had. Unforgiven, the woman committed suicide, leaving Haru in her grandfather’s care. The final confrontation and reconciliation between Haru and her father brings some emotional closure, but certainly doesn’t bring them together. Noboku invites the old man to live with them, but Haru and Tadao run off together, realizing that in this hard world, they are the best lifelines for each other.

The emotional tenor of “Haru’s Journey” revels in the subtle changes and revelations of each character’s background, relationships and arc in the dynamics of this “typical” family. The main reference is Ozu’s “Tokyo Story.” Even the casting of Chikage Awashima, who worked with Ozu, creates an historical link. Kobayashi himself has pointedly said that “Haru’s Journey” is his own “Tokyo Story.”

Mostly eschewing his own austere visual style – though there are some visual repetitions – Kobayashi in “Haru’s Journey” shoots much in close-up and with shallow-focus, forefronting performance and actorly nuance over the visual and emotional spaces he generally highlights in his films. If there is one Kobayishi-ism that remains in Haru, it’s his character’s voraciousness in consuming food. In most of his films, his characters eat, often alone and more often with an almost insane lack of fulfillment – stuffing their faces with endless amounts of convenience store or cafeteria food. In Haru, there’s plenty of eating, but this time with grandfather and granddaughter sharing in not only the physical, but the emotional pleasures of breaking bread – or rather noodles – together. The one exception that harkens back to early Kobayashi is a strange and touching scene early on where Tadao chugs a couple of one-cups, only to pass out.

Though “Haru’s Journey” may on the surface seem a more conservative exploration of Japanese society than the likes of “Bashing” or “The Rebirth,” the stunning performances of all involved – especially Nakadai – shows Kobayashi digging deeper into emotional truths. Nakadai as Tadao, – old, but still restless under the skin, twitching with tics – creates a decidedly old-fashioned everyman, resonating with tragedy and backhanded hope. Part of Kobayishi’s genius here is in allowing Nakadai to take the character of Tadao into uncharted territory, creating yet another career defining performance.

Originally published in Toronto J-Film Pow-Wow, March 12, 2011


hospitalité / 歓待

leave a comment »

Like a sitcom gone out of control, Koji Fukata’s second feature, hospitalité, would work better as television or as the theatrical production it started as. Fukata is a member of the Seinendan theatre company, known for their contemporary theatre works that on the surface carry an almost manifesto-like rejection of western theatrical traditions, but more deeply seem to be a variation of skit comedy. hospitalité looks and feels like filmed theatre. The situation in hospitalité involves Mikio (Yamauchi Kenji) and his wife, Natsuki (Sugino Kiki), owners of a small print shop in Tokyo.  A certain Kagawa (Kanji Furutachi) appears. He insinuates himself into a job. Soon he’s living with them with his suspect “wife,” a gaijin who manages to claim different nationalities. By the time she seduces Mikio, the die is set for Kagawa to up the ante, bringing in a crew of gaijin to live in their cramped house. This trickster’s motivations are never explained and by the end all have disappeared except Mikio, Natsuki and their daughter – everything back to normal, but changed.

Originally published in EL Magazine, April 2011

Written by Nicholas Vroman

March 28, 2011 at 7:46 am


leave a comment »

On paper the plot sounds interesting. Over-stressed office worker, Hae-won (Seo Young-he), goes for some R and R to an off-the-map island where she lived with her grandparents as a child. She reunites with her childhood friend, Bok-nam (Ji Sung-won) and soon discovers what a horrific and degraded life she has living amongst a community of tropical hillbillies. The situation goes from bad to worse with Bok-nam finally losing it, getting her revenge and making dead meat of her brutal sexist husband, his creepy idiot brother, and a quartet of bitter old crones (including her step-mother) who maintain the perverse status-quo of their insular community. First-time director Jang Cheol-soo directs his actors with broad swipes, painting archetypical caricatures. He sets up a fun foreboding milieu. Then he throws it all away with a grotesque, psychologically suspect and mostly, incoherent gore fest that goes on far too long and ultimately sinks whatever good things set up at the beginning. By the time the bloody and crazed Bok-nam finally dies, one’s past the point of caring.

Originally published in EL Magazine, April 2011

Written by Nicholas Vroman

March 28, 2011 at 7:43 am

Mahoro ekimae tada benriken / まほろ駅前多田便利軒

leave a comment »

Despite the genial chemistry between stars Ryûhei Matsuda (Gohatto, Boys on the Run) and Eita (Dear Doctor, Toad’s Oil), Mahoro ekimae tada benriken’s wandering plot and offhand asides make for a directionless and ultimately unsatisfying ride. Tatsushi Omori, whose A Crowd of Three suffered from a similar sort laziness in direction, has tried to make a slacker something-or-other that’s neither comic nor culturally incisive enough to merit much laughter or discussion. Based on Shion Miura’s 2006 Naoko prize winning novel of the same name, the wandering story follows the lives of a fix-it man (Eita) and his sidekick (Matsuda) as their lives intersect with a handful of moderately colorful characters that they run across as they go about their odd jobs. These few loose subplots that pepper the larger arc of the primary buddy relationship are mostly inconsequential and not particularly well developed. Plus there’s a basic sexism in Omori’s worldview – not quite as heinous as his treatment of Sakura Ando in his previous film – that rears its ugly head in his new oeuvre.

Originally published in EL Magazine, April 2011